• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Career Vision

Contact Us | Client Login | 630-469-6270
  • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Testimonials
  • The Aptitude Advantage
    • The Aptitude Advantage
    • Aptitude-Based Career Planning
    • Community Education Programs
  • PROGRAMS & PRICING
    • Career Readiness Program
    • Career Launch Program
    • Career Management Program
    • Situational Career Consultation
  • Parents
    • Parents
    • Discover Strengths
    • Develop Options
    • Direction to Success
  • Students
    • Students
    • High School
    • College
  • Career Change
    • Career Management & Transitions
    • Launch & Early Career
    • Career Changers & Mid-Career
    • Late Career
    • Free Career Quizzes
    • Job Search Groups
Facebooktwitterlinkedin
Critical Ingredients of Career Interventions

We would like to share with you the following article from the National Career Development Association on best practices for career interventions. Some of the research cited in this article is based on the meta-analyses that one of our consultants, Nancy Ryan, Ph.D., conducted for her dissertation. Dr. Ryan and a former Career Vision consultant, Laurie Mattera, Ph.D., (FKA Edens), contributed to a second article as well. Career Vision’s Advantage Packages are designed to incorporate these best practices, giving our clients the best chance of accomplishing their goals.

Have you ever wondered which career counseling interventions are most effective? A number of researchers (i.e., Oliver and Spokane (1988), Whiston, Sexton, and Lasoff (1998) have conducted meta-analyses of research studies on career counseling interventions to find out. Although these studies have clearly established that career counseling is effective when administered individually, in groups, to classes, or via computer-assisted guidance, they have shed less light on which interventions are most effective, with exception that self-directed interventions tend to be less effective. However, a meta-analysis described by Brown and Ryan Krane (2000) examined the components included in a large collection of research studies and found significant differences in effectiveness of interventions that include certain critical ingredients. Examining the components of 62 career intervention studies, 18 components were identified, from card-sorts to computerized systems (Brown et al, 2003). By comparing the effectiveness of these 62 studies based on the components used in the intervention, five components were found to make a significant contribution to the effectiveness of the intervention.

The five components that increased effectiveness were:

  • workbooks or written exercises
  • individualized interpretations and feedback
  • world-of-work information
  • modeling
  • attention to building support

Further, using more than one of these components appeared to increase the effectiveness of the intervention. Studies that contained none of these components achieved an average effectiveness rating of .22. Those with one, two, ore three of these components averaged .45, .61, and .99 respectively. None of the studies examined included more than three of these five components. Every one of the five components raises as many questions as it answers. Exactly how should it be implemented for greatest effect? How can it be adapted to specific settings and clients? Do different clients respond differently to the five components? As we focus on these issues, we may find ways to further increase our effectiveness. This tantalizing glimpse into the keys to success begs for experimentation and research into the effectiveness of the many possible variations of these components.

References

Brown, S.D., & Ryan Krane, N.E. (2000). Four (or five) sessions and a cloud of dust: Old assumptions and new observations about career counseling. In S.D. Brown & R.W. Lent (Eds.),Handbook of Counseling Psychology (3rd ed., pp. 740-766). New York: Wiley.

Brown, S.D., & Ryan Krane, N.E., Brecheisen, J., Castelino, P., Budisen, I., Miller, M., and Edens. L. (2003). Critical ingredients of career choice interventions: More analyses and new hypotheses.Journal of Vocational Behavior, 62, 411-428.

Oliver, L.W., & Spokane, A.R. (1988). Career-counseling outcome: What contributes to client gain?Journal of Counseling Psychology, 35, 447-462.

Whiston, S.C., Secton, T.L., & Lasoff, D.L. (1998). Career-intervention outcome: A replication and extension of Oliver and Spokane (1998). Journal of Counseling Psychology, 45, 150-165.

Bio:
Marilyn Maze, Ph.D., is a Field Editor for Career Convergence and a Principal Research Associate for ACT, Inc.

This article originally appeared in NCDA’s newsletter, Career Developments, at http://www.ncda.org. Copyright National Career Development Association, (December, 2007). Reprinted with permission.

Primary Sidebar

Questions?

phone

  • FAQs
  • Interested in a speakers or events?
  • E-newsletter ~ Read and subscribe!
  • Looking for Articles & Resources?

Now confident about college choice

 

From the Career Vision Articles

  • Our Children Are Going To College, But Do They Know Why?

See more articles and resources

I would love this job!

 

From the Career Vision Articles

  • The Power Of Informational Interviews
  • College Visits Webinar

See more articles and resources

All I knew was I didn’t want a 9-5 job

 

Tip of the Month!

  • Tip of the Month for High School Students: Explore Your Interests through Academic Summer Camps

See more articles and resources

Son now thrilled with major and looking forward to job

 

Tip of the Month!

  • Tip of the Month for College Students: Discover Your Learning Preferences

See more articles and resources

A new perspective made work much more enjoyable

 

I targeted a position that fits my profile absolutely perfectly

 

From the Career Vision Articles

    See more articles and resources

    Helped me pinpoint frustration at work & understand what to look for

     

    From the Career Vision Articles

      See more articles and resources

      My results were startling

       

      From the Career Vision Articles

        See more articles and resources

        From the Career Vision Articles

        • Tip of the Month for Working Adults: Identify Your Work Values

        See more articles and resources

        I got bragging rights!

         

        New options gave us new hope

         

        Strategic direction saved us

         

        Founders
        Board of Directors

        Meet our Team

        CV sign main streetCareer Vision is a service mark of
        The Ball Foundation

        Typical Parental Investments

        Solid methodology provided direction to success & happiness

         

        Compared to an extra year or 2 of college, Career Vision cost is "a drop in the bucket"

        Article Archive

        See the full Career Vision Archive

        Where We’ve Presented

        See where we've done presentations.

        Career Vision Scholarship Winner

        Career Vision Scholarship Winner

        Subscribe

        Keep Informed

        Are you a parent or student who likes to stay informed? An adult who wants to take charge of your career? A high school, college or business professional who knows the importance of career planning and success? Subscribe to our newsletter to keep informed about:

        • Career Literacy and Career Management
        • Career and college success tips
        • Job trends and statistics
        • Upcoming presentations and events
        • Resources for practical decision-making throughout your career

        Career Readiness Brochure

        Download our Start Early, Start SMART Career Readiness Brochure

        $$ Research Membership $$

        As a research organization we are committed to the highest professional standards and practice. To help facilitate this ongoing research, we offer an optional Research Membership.

        A Research Membership entitles you to a $100 discount on any program combination you select along with unlimited* free follow up consultations. In exchange, we ask that you complete two short surveys annually. Your information will continue to support our outcome research and work on aptitudes and career paths. Please mention your interest at registration.

        * Up to 2 consultations annually

        Career Launch & Early Career Brochure

        Download our Start SMART Career Launch & Early Career Brochure

        $$ Research Membership $$

        As a research organization we are committed to the highest professional standards and practice. To help facilitate this ongoing research, we offer an optional Research Membership.

        A Research Membership entitles you to a $100 discount on any program combination you select along with unlimited* free follow up consultations. In exchange, we ask that you complete two short surveys annually. Your information will continue to support our outcome research and work on aptitudes and career paths. Please mention your interest at registration.

        * Up to 2 consultations annually

        Career Management & Transitions Brochure

        Download our Career Management & Transitions Brochure

         

        $$ Research Membership $$

        As a research organization we are committed to the highest professional standards and practice. To help facilitate this ongoing research, we offer an optional Research Membership.

        A Research Membership entitles you to a $100 discount on any program combination you select along with unlimited* free follow up consultations. In exchange, we ask that you complete two short surveys annually. Your information will continue to support our outcome research and work on aptitudes and career paths. Please mention your interest at registration.

        * Up to 2 consultations annually

        parents with sonParents are the #1 influence on their children, but most don't have the experience to confidently guide career development.

        See more information for parents.

        Understand Your Job Satisfaction

        green cube smiley happy

        Take our free Job Satisfaction Survey

        Understand your Job Satisfaction

        green cube smiley happy

        Take our free Job Satisfaction Survey

        Copyright © 1990–2025 The Ball Foundation · Contact Us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Staff Email